
For those of you who are not yet familiar with Lala.com, it is a new ad free online music player and storefront. The concept behind Lala is promising and will likely inspire moves in the right direction for regulating online streaming and iTunes alternatives, but the reality is that the service is not ready to do what it promises.
In theory, Lala allows users to stream any song in their 6,000,000 track catalogue free of charge at least once (any listen under 30 seconds does not count) and then an unlimited number of times for $.10. Users may then elect to download mp3s of tracks for an additional $.70 or so and albums for a corresponding nominal fee. This part of the service seems to function properly and is actually useful for listening on the go and quick references.
Where Lala seemed poised to blaze trails but actually disappoints is the idea that users could have their personal music libraries matched through the site to be played from any computer free of charge while streaming from ‘the cloud’. This would essentially render hard disk space a non-issue and imbue the service with significant value. The mechanics behind the process involve downloading the Lala MusicMover which analyzes the user’s personal library matching songs that it recognized in its proprietary catalog (what it refers to as the ‘fast way’) and then uploading any tracks that it is unable to recognize to its server.
I first downloaded the Lala MusicMover almost exactly a month ago and have it running in the background almost constantly since. I am almost invariably connected to one of two high speed broadband connections and am generally able to download/upload anything with a high degree of celerity. MusicMover, however, does not seem willing to oblige as (in the month it has been running) it has only managed to match/upload about 3,000 of my 9,643 track library (only about 300 of which actually show up on the Lala site for streaming from the cloud) and cause my computer and internet browsers to malfunction and crash repeatedly.
Lala is an interesting idea in theory but the service needs serious improvement in order for it to achieve any degree of success. After my experience with the MusicMover, I have elected to terminate the upload/matching and wait for something better to come along.